Unfamiliar threat? Apply the warning basics

Whenever the Warn Room conducts a training exercise for a large group, we always include an unfamiliar threat as a way to test participant knowledge. If you've been in one of our trainings, you know what this training scenario entails... Dr. Hive is an entomologist whose bee colony goes missing and we don't know how or when they left/escaped/were bee-napped, etc. It's up to you to write the message and alert the right people. Oftentimes, this exercise turns a quiet room into tables buzzing with energy, leading to sweet little messages at the end.
You'd be surprised at how people much people really dig into this activity. When presented to forecasters, they investigate the temperatures, wind patterns, and biology of bees; when presented to crisis communication students, they add a url where people can post their pictures and tips or call 1-800-bee-seen. See, learning about warnings can be FUN!
So, when we saw an alert issued for an unfamiliar threat this week, we had to check it out. And readers, it was good! [Note that this is not a commentary on whether the message SHOULD be issued - by whom, or how. Additional evacuation advisory messages went out to persons who signed up for local alerts. Those messages included zones and recommended that people "close doors and windows" to protect breathing.]

Let's set the scene. It's afternoon in California when a "geyser of material and thick plume of gaseoous steam" shot more than 500 feet into the air at a landfill. This occurred when workers were drilling a hole deep into a mountain of trash and hit a pocket of gas. Initially described as an explosion, it was later determined that the plume was not smoke, but the gases being released from rotting garbage. It was seen for miles and certainly carried an unmistakeable smell. You can watch reporting of it here.
You can bet that the County received many calls asking about air quality, impacts to health, and the safety of those who were nearby. Seeing this WEA suggests that it may have been issued not as a warning but as a strategy to relieve the uncertainty that would go along with a toxic event like this.
The message includes a source (in acronym form), date, and time. The hazard is a "methane leak" and the location is the "Chiquita Canyon landfill." Then they get to the heart of the message: This message is for awareness and here's what we're doing to manage things.
This is like crisis communication 101 rolled into a WEA message. The Situational Crisis Communication Theory says to provide clear instructing and adjusting information to help people understand what has happened and how it is being managed. In other words, tell people what you know, tell people what you don't know, and tell people what you're doing to find out.
What they say:
Fire Department personnel are on scene
They are monitoring the air.
Right now, the air monitoring is negative (meaning it is not dangerous).
If air monitoring results require public action, they will provide that information.
Here's another place to get more information [url]
What they do not provide is any indication that actions are needed. There is no instruction to close doors and windows, to turn off heating or air conditioning, to avoid the area, etc. That might make a person wonder, especially if the air smells like rotting garbage AND they got the local alert telling them to prepare to evacuate.
What I appreciate about this alert is how warning principles can be seen in the message. It is clear, it contains the key contents that need to be included in an alert, regardless of how threatening it might be. It also connects with people's fear and uncertainty by providing adjusting information in the form of organizational response information: that is, information about what the organization is doing to manage the threat.
This would be a great case study on communication. Here are some questions I'd want answered. Did this WEA relieve people's fears and concerns? Did it exacerbate them given the long history neighbors have with this particular landfill? Did it build trust between neighbors and authorities who are actively managing the threat? How did it intersect with the notification that was issued by the city? Did people understand what an evacuation advisory meant? Did the city alert appear to be contradictory to the LASD message, which gives no hint of danger?
Lot's to think about on this one. But it still remains an exemplar to demonstrate the principles of a good alert, even when the situation is uncertain.
For more help on your alerts and warnings, be sure to read the Warn Room blogs. And watch for the new Handbook for Public Alerts and Warnings, coming soon!




Comments